Part of the series: Living, Loving, and Leading in a Liminal Season
Part of living, loving, and leading in a liminal season is casting nets, not just one line, and seeing what comes up. And if a bunch of fish come up, then you decide what to do with them. We try things, learn from the messiness and failures of mission, and organize around what begins to grow.
I’ve come to realize our culture is petrified of failure. People will plan, prep, perfect, and then revisit the plan obsessively to avoid failure or even the appearance of failure. (Our culture is also petrified of apologizing and terrible at it, but I’ll save that for another time.)
Failure is unavoidable. It’s going to happen.
We moved from the Midwest to Silver Spring, Maryland, in 2011. My brother, sister-in-law, and their kids joined us. My wife and I had been hired to start a church, and we didn’t know a soul in the area.
In the “church planting world,” this is about as risky as it gets: go to a place you’re unfamiliar with, where you have no relationships, and try to start something from scratch.
We started the grind of getting to know Silver Spring, meeting people, and building a core team. About 12 months in, we had around 10–15 people, and one of us had an idea. I can’t remember who, but it went something like this:
Let’s attend the local July 4th parade in our Restore Church T-shirts, print some invitation postcards, hand them out, and ask for names and email addresses so we can invite people to our small, growing community.
I thought, “Oh, this will be great! We’ll have hours of access to potentially thousands of people who are ready to interact. After all, they’re attending a parade!”
Our team scattered for hours, handing out postcards and greeting people. Our big goal: get names and contact info so we could follow up.
At the close of the parade, we reconvened. Between the 15 of us, we got one person’s contact info. One.
Hours of work. Hundreds of dollars spent on T-shirts and postcards. One person.
FYI: They never responded to my follow-up.
I gathered our dejected team (and yeah, everyone looked and felt it) and laughed.
I don’t remember my exact words, but I said something like, “Wow, this bombed, didn’t it? What an epic failure!”
Then something like, “Hey, that’s mission for you. We tried something and figured out this isn’t the approach to take. Important lesson learned.”
It wasn’t the last thing that failed.
Over the years of starting and pastoring our church, we tried a lot of different missional moves. We failed more often than we succeeded. But ultimately, we got it started, and Restore Church is still going today. She just celebrated her 15th anniversary last Sunday.
I think what Karrie and I are most thankful for from our church planting and pastoring experience is the relationships that formed among those people. So many Restore folks have scattered and moved (that’s the nature of the Washington, D.C., area), but the friendships have continued. Those relationships are still blessing us.
I’m glad we didn’t give up after a failed endeavor. I’m glad we kept experimenting and trying.
“Innovation rarely occurs in a linear manner...and relies on the presence of diversity.”
— Susan Beaumont, author of How to Lead When You Don’t Know Where You’re Going
Seeds and Water Collective was born out of Restore Church people saying, “This needs to grow. What we are doing here in Silver Spring needs to expand to other places.”
FYI: Every Seeds and Water board member was part of Restore Church.
Seeds and Water is now approaching 300 clients served over the past five years.
What if we had given up after experiencing missional failure? What friendships, what healing, what possibilities might we have missed?
Failure is part of liminality. Embrace it. Learn from it. Try again. See what comes.
And when something begins to bear fruit, start organizing and strategizing around it.
Cast the nets again.